top of page

Common Areas of Deficiencies in Big Four PCAOB 2023 Inspection Reports

Writer's picture: John C. Blackshire, Jr.John C. Blackshire, Jr.

The PCAOB inspection reports for the Big Four audit firms highlight several common areas of recurring deficiencies:

  1. Internal Control Over Financial Reporting (ICFR):

    • Deficiencies frequently stem from inadequate testing of design and operational effectiveness of controls.

    • Common issues include failure to test the accuracy and completeness of data used in controls, especially in high-risk accounts like revenue and inventory.

  2. Revenue Recognition:

    • Revenue-related deficiencies are prevalent, often due to insufficient substantive testing and risk assessment.

    • Specific issues include ineffective testing of controls related to revenue recognition, especially under complex arrangements, and inadequate validation of the accuracy and completeness of revenue data.

  3. Investment Valuations and Accounting Estimates:

    • Many audits faced challenges in validating fair value estimates, particularly for investment securities, goodwill, and intangible assets.

    • Deficiencies include insufficient testing of assumptions, data, and models used for fair value and impairment assessments.

  4. Inventory Valuation:

    • Common issues involve inadequate testing of inventory reserves, especially for last-in, first-out (LIFO) and cycle-count controls.

    • Insufficient testing of the existence and valuation of inventory, as well as testing controls over these processes, is a recurring theme.

  5. Allowance for Credit Losses (ACL) and Loan Losses:

    • In audits involving credit losses, firms often had issues with evaluating the adequacy of controls over ACL and the assumptions used.

    • Deficiencies included insufficient sampling and testing of credit loss models and lack of attention to significant data points in estimating losses.

  6. Substantive Analytical Procedures:

    • Auditors often relied on analytical procedures without verifying that underlying data was relevant and reliable.

    • Common issues included using non-predictive data, failing to establish precise expectations, and inadequate follow-up on discrepancies.

  7. Audit Documentation:

    • Instances were identified where audit teams failed to include necessary documentation to support audit conclusions.

    • Documentation deficiencies, particularly related to critical audit matters (CAMs) and uncorrected misstatements, affected the completeness and quality of audit records.

  8. Risk Assessment and Material Misstatement:

    • Risk assessment issues involved inadequate evaluation of risks related to significant accounts and disclosures.

    • Firms frequently failed to identify significant risks or address them appropriately, especially in complex audit areas like revenue and business combinations.

These areas highlight the complexity and challenges in auditing high-risk accounts, internal controls, and fair value estimates, emphasizing the need for rigorous testing and documentation practices in these domains.



14 views0 comments

Comentários


Contact Us

Please white list the email address johnb@cseminars.com to allow for CCS emails to reach you effectively.

Thanks for submitting!

Corporate Compliance Seminars is registered with the National Association of State Boards of Accountancy (NASBA) as a sponsor of continuing professional education on the National Registry of CPE Sponsors. State boards of accountancy have final authority on the acceptance of individual courses for CPE credit. Complaints regarding registered sponsors may be submitted to the National Registry of CPE Sponsors through its website: www.nasbaregistry.org.

In accordance with the standards of the National Registry of CPE Sponsors, CPE credits are granted based on a 50-minute hour.

National Registry of CPE Sponsors ID #108983

Complaints may also be forwarded to the company principals, David S. Marshall (708-205-2366davem@cseminars.com) and/ or John Blackshire (479-200-4373johnb@cseminars.com)

 

At CCS, we are deeply dedicated to delivering NASBA-sponsored Continuing Professional Education (CPE) training events focusing on vital subjects such as risk management, audit & assurance, internal controls, internal audit, cybersecurity, and compliance. Our educational content is meticulously crafted to be accessible through live webinars and in-person CPE events, custom-tailored to meet the CPE requirements of certifications including CIA, CPA, CISA, CFE, and other professional certifications.

We take immense pride in our pivotal role over the past twenty years of empowering participants to expand their audit expertise and develop a deep understanding of best-practice frameworks and standards established by eminent organizations such as IIA, AICPA, COSO Framework, PCAOB Auditing Standards, NAIC Model Laws, GAO Green Book, GAO Yellow Book, NIST, ISO, CMMC, ACFE, SEC, and IAASB.

Our comprehensive CPE training events provide invaluable insights across a diverse spectrum of topics, encompassing internal auditing, external audits, planning and execution of audits using the PCAOB Auditing Standards, formulation and implementation of effective internal audits, risk identification and evaluation, adherence to accounting and auditing standards, proficient management of business endeavors and projects, ITGCs and application controls, vigilant oversight of vendor and third-party risks, robust cybersecurity initiatives, and the reporting of audit, risk management, and internal control training courses.

Furthermore, we offer our professional attendees the opportunity to engage with our webinar CPE events virtually, featuring live instructors, or to participate in-person at select cities or a location of their choice.

We consider our target audience to include chief audit executives, audit partners in CPA firms, chief compliance officers, audit managers, audit supervisors, external auditors, internal auditors, internal control professionals, quality control professionals, compliance professionals, board members, and other professionals who prioritize continuous improvement and organizational sustainability.

Our CPE events are all based on the professional standards provided by the IIA, AICPA, PCAOB Auditing Standards, SEC, ISACA, ACFE, NAIC regulations, NIST, ISO, CMMC, COSO Framework, GAO Yellow Book, GAO Green Book, U.S. GAAP, IFRS, and IAASB.

The CCS training staff has a broad range of experience in internal auditing, Big 4 auditing, software development and implementation, Big 4 consulting, governmental accounting and auditing, regulatory compliance and professional training.

Our flexibility in delivering content allows us to cater to the diverse needs of our professional audit function, internal control professional and information technology participants, ensuring a truly enriching learning experience for all.

Explore our CPE event offerings and sign up for your first CPE training event today!

bottom of page