top of page
Search

Recalculation and Reperformance Explained: Two Essential Audit Evidence Techniques

6 minutes ago
12 min read

How auditors independently verify mathematical accuracy, test internal controls, and obtain reliable audit evidence under PCAOB AS 1105


Auditors frequently encounter financial information that appears accurate, properly documented, and approved by management.


A spreadsheet may contain the correct formulas. A bank reconciliation may have been signed by a supervisor. A depreciation schedule may agree to the general ledger.


But does that evidence establish that the information is correct or that the underlying control operated effectively?


Not necessarily.


Two important audit procedures—recalculation and reperformance—help auditors independently evaluate financial information and internal controls rather than relying exclusively on management's representations.


Both procedures are recognized under PCAOB AS 1105, Audit Evidence.


Although they are closely related, they serve different audit objectives.


Recalculation addresses mathematical accuracy.


Reperformance addresses the independent execution of a procedure or control originally performed by the organization.


Understanding the distinction is essential for external auditors, internal auditors, SOX compliance professionals, and anyone responsible for testing internal controls over financial reporting.


1. What Is Recalculation?

PCAOB AS 1105.19 defines recalculation as checking the mathematical accuracy of information.


Recalculation involves independently verifying calculations using appropriate mathematical procedures.


The auditor may perform the calculation manually, using a spreadsheet, or through audit software.


Common examples include:

  • Recalculating invoice extensions.

  • Recomputing depreciation expense.

  • Verifying payroll deductions.

  • Recalculating loan interest.

  • Checking inventory valuation extensions.

  • Recomputing tax calculations.

  • Verifying financial statement totals.

  • Recalculating the mathematical components of accounting estimates.


Example: Recalculating Depreciation

Assume a company purchases equipment with the following characteristics:

Item

Amount

Original cost

$120,000

Estimated salvage value

$20,000

Estimated useful life

5 years

Depreciation method

Straight-line


The annual depreciation calculation is: ($120,000 − $20,000) ÷ 5 = $20,000


If management records $18,000 in annual depreciation, the auditor identifies a $2,000 difference from the independently calculated amount.


The auditor must investigate the difference.


However, recalculation alone does not establish that the five-year useful life or $20,000 salvage value is reasonable.


Those assumptions require separate audit evaluation.


Recalculation verifies mathematical accuracy. It does not automatically establish that the underlying assumptions or accounting treatment are appropriate.


2. What Is Reperformance?

PCAOB AS 1105.20 defines reperformance as the auditor's independent execution of procedures or controls originally performed by company personnel.


The auditor does not merely examine evidence that management performed the procedure.


Instead, the auditor independently executes the relevant procedure or control to determine whether it produces the expected result.


Reperformance is particularly useful in testing the operating effectiveness of internal controls.


Example: Reperforming a Three-Way Match

A company requires accounts payable personnel to match three documents before approving payment:

  1. Purchase order.

  2. Receiving report.

  3. Vendor invoice.


The control is designed to prevent payment for unauthorized purchases, incorrect quantities, or unsupported invoices.


An auditor selects a purchase transaction and independently performs the three-way match.


The auditor compares the vendor, item, quantity, price, and relevant approval information.


If the documents do not agree, the auditor determines whether the company's control appropriately identified and resolved the discrepancy.


The auditor is not simply checking arithmetic.


The auditor is independently performing the control activity.


3. Recalculation Versus Reperformance

The distinction can be summarized as follows.

Characteristic

Recalculation

Reperformance

Primary purpose

Verify mathematical accuracy

Independently execute a procedure or control

Typical subject

Calculations and numerical information

Control activities and processing procedures

Common application

Substantive testing

Tests of controls

Example

Recalculate depreciation

Reperform a bank reconciliation review

Evidence obtained

Whether the calculation is mathematically accurate

Whether the independently executed procedure produces the expected result

Principal limitation

Does not necessarily validate inputs or assumptions

Does not automatically establish that management performed the control consistently

Recalculation can be one component of reperformance.


For example, independently performing a bank reconciliation may involve recalculating the adjusted cash balance.


However, recalculating the adjusted cash balance alone does not constitute reperformance of the entire reconciliation and review process.


4. Why These Procedures Provide Valuable Audit Evidence

PCAOB AS 1105 requires auditors to obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence.

Sufficiency concerns the quantity of evidence.


Appropriateness concerns its relevance and reliability.


Evidence obtained directly by the auditor is generally more reliable than evidence obtained indirectly.


Recalculation and reperformance can provide persuasive evidence because the auditor independently performs the work.


However, their effectiveness depends on whether the procedure addresses the relevant audit objective.


For example, recalculating the total of an accounts receivable aging report does not establish that every receivable is included.


Similarly, independently performing a control once does not necessarily establish that management performed it effectively throughout the year.


The auditor must connect the procedure to the relevant assertion or control objective.


5. Recalculation in Substantive Audit Procedures

Recalculation is commonly used when testing financial statement amounts.


Accounts Receivable

The auditor may recalculate invoice amounts using quantities, unit prices, discounts, and applicable taxes.


Payroll

The auditor may independently compute gross wages, overtime, and payroll deductions.


Inventory

The auditor may recalculate quantity multiplied by unit cost and verify the resulting extensions.


Interest Expense

The auditor may calculate interest using the principal balance, contractual rate, and applicable time period.


Depreciation

The auditor may recompute depreciation based on cost, residual value, useful life, and depreciation method.


Accounting Estimates

The auditor may verify mathematical components of a valuation model.

However, when estimates involve significant assumptions, PCAOB AS 2501 may require additional procedures addressing the estimation method, underlying data, and significant assumptions.


Recalculation is only one part of obtaining sufficient appropriate evidence.


6. Reperformance in Tests of Controls

Reperformance is particularly important when the auditor needs evidence about the operation of a control.


Consider the following examples.

Internal control

Auditor's reperformance procedure

Bank reconciliations

Independently reconcile the bank balance to the general ledger using relevant supporting records

Three-way matching

Independently compare purchase orders, receiving reports, and invoices

Credit limit controls

Reapply the established credit approval criteria to selected transactions

Inventory reconciliations

Independently reconcile inventory records to the relevant control accounts

User access reviews

Independently apply the access review criteria to selected users and permissions

Journal entry review

Independently apply the documented review criteria to selected journal entries

An important limitation applies.


When the auditor reperforms a control, the auditor establishes what happens when the procedure is independently executed.


The auditor must still obtain appropriate evidence that the company's personnel performed the control at the required frequency and with sufficient competence and precision.


For example, successfully reperforming a reconciliation does not prove that the accounting manager reviewed it each month.


7. Example: Reperforming a Bank Reconciliation

Assume a company reports the following:

Item

Amount

Bank statement ending balance

$525,000

Deposits in transit

$45,000

Outstanding checks

($70,000)

Adjusted bank balance

$500,000

General ledger cash balance

$500,000

The reconciliation balances.


However, the auditor should not conclude that the reconciliation control was effective solely because the arithmetic is correct.


A reperformance procedure might include:

  1. Obtaining the bank statement independently or evaluating its reliability.

  2. Agreeing the general ledger balance to the accounting records.

  3. Testing selected deposits in transit to subsequent bank activity.

  4. Testing selected outstanding checks to subsequent clearing activity.

  5. Investigating unusual or old reconciling items.

  6. Independently calculating the adjusted balances.

  7. Evaluating whether the preparer identified and resolved relevant differences.

  8. Examining evidence that the required reviewer performed the control.


The auditor's work addresses more than arithmetic.


It evaluates whether the reconciliation procedure appropriately identifies differences between bank and accounting records.


The review component must also be evaluated when it is part of the control being tested.


8. Reperformance and Management Review Controls

Management review controls require special attention.


Examples include:

  • Monthly budget-to-actual reviews.

  • Financial statement fluctuation reviews.

  • Journal entry approval.

  • Account reconciliation reviews.

  • Credit loss allowance reviews.

  • Revenue recognition reviews.


These controls often involve judgment.


Reperformance requires the auditor to understand the criteria and precision of the review.


Example: Monthly Financial Review

A CFO reviews monthly financial statements and investigates unusual variances.


The auditor should determine:

  • What information the CFO reviews.

  • What constitutes an unusual variance.

  • What thresholds trigger investigation.

  • Whether the information is complete and accurate.

  • How exceptions are investigated.

  • Whether identified errors are corrected.

  • What evidence demonstrates the review occurred.


The auditor may independently analyze selected variances using the criteria established for the control.


However, performing a more extensive analysis than management originally performed does not establish that management's actual review was sufficiently precise.


The auditor must evaluate the control that management actually performed—not a stronger control created by the auditor during testing.


9. Recalculation Does Not Establish Completeness

One of the most important limitations of recalculation is that it may verify the arithmetic of incomplete information.


Example: Payroll Register

An auditor receives a payroll register containing 500 employees.


The auditor recalculates gross wages and deductions for selected employees.


All calculations are correct.


However, the company actually employs 525 individuals.


Twenty-five employees were omitted from the register.


The auditor's recalculation does not detect the incomplete population unless additional procedures address completeness.


Under AS 1105.10, when using information produced by the company as audit evidence, the auditor must perform appropriate procedures concerning accuracy, completeness, and sufficient precision and detail.


The auditor should not confuse correct calculations with reliable underlying information.


10. Reperformance Does Not Automatically Establish Operating Effectiveness

Suppose an auditor independently performs a monthly reconciliation and obtains the correct result.


This demonstrates that the procedure can produce the expected outcome when appropriately executed.


But it does not necessarily establish that management performed the reconciliation throughout the audit period.


To evaluate operating effectiveness, the auditor may also need to determine:

  • Whether the control operated at the required frequency.

  • Whether the assigned employee performed it.

  • Whether the employee possessed appropriate competence and authority.

  • Whether exceptions were identified.

  • Whether exceptions were resolved.

  • Whether the control operated consistently over the relevant period.


PCAOB AS 2201 addresses the testing of design and operating effectiveness in integrated audits.


Reperformance can provide persuasive evidence, but it must be considered alongside the nature, timing, and extent of the auditor's other procedures.


11. Recalculation, Reperformance, Inspection, and Observation

Auditors should understand how these procedures differ.

Procedure

What the auditor does

Example

Inspection

Examines records, documents, or physical assets

Reviews a signed reconciliation

Observation

Watches another person perform a procedure

Observes an inventory count

Recalculation

Independently checks mathematical accuracy

Recalculates depreciation

Reperformance

Independently executes a procedure or control

Reperforms a reconciliation

Inquiry

Obtains information from knowledgeable individuals

Asks the CFO how the reconciliation is reviewed

Each procedure provides different evidence.


For example, observing an employee perform a control establishes what occurred during the observation.


It does not necessarily establish that the control operated consistently throughout the year.



Similarly, inspecting a signed reconciliation may establish evidence of approval but may not demonstrate that the reviewer performed a sufficiently precise review.

Combining procedures may provide stronger evidence.


12. Reperformance Under PCAOB AS 2201

PCAOB AS 2201 addresses audits of internal control over financial reporting integrated with financial statement audits.


The standard explains that auditors should test whether controls are appropriately designed and operating effectively.


AS 2201.50 identifies several types of procedures used in control testing and explains that, ordinarily, they provide increasing levels of evidence in this order:

  1. Inquiry.

  2. Observation.

  3. Inspection of relevant documentation.

  4. Reperformance.


This ordering is not an automatic rule that reperformance must always be performed.


The appropriate combination of procedures depends on the nature of the control, associated risks, and evidence necessary to support the audit conclusion.


Inquiry alone is insufficient to support a conclusion about a control's effectiveness.


Reperformance is often especially useful for controls involving identifiable, repeatable procedures.


13. Using Recalculation and Reperformance in Internal Auditing

Although PCAOB standards apply to relevant external audit engagements, the techniques are equally useful to internal auditors.


Internal auditors may use recalculation and reperformance when evaluating operational, financial, compliance, and information technology controls.


Procurement Audit

Recalculate invoice amounts and independently reperform purchase authorization checks.

Payroll Audit

Recalculate compensation and independently evaluate selected payroll approval procedures.

Banking Audit

Recalculate interest and fees and reperform selected transaction monitoring procedures.

Insurance Audit

Recalculate premium amounts and independently execute selected underwriting control checks.

Government Audit

Recalculate grant expenditures and independently apply eligibility or expenditure approval criteria.


The objective is to determine whether the procedures provide reliable evidence concerning the audit criteria.


14. Automated Controls and Reperformance

Organizations increasingly rely on automated application controls.


Examples include:

  • Automated credit limit checks.

  • Duplicate invoice detection.

  • System-enforced approval thresholds.

  • Automated tax calculations.

  • Three-way matching rules.

  • Automated interest calculations.


Auditors may test these controls by independently executing transactions through an appropriately controlled test environment or evaluating system processing against independently established expected results.


Example: Automated Approval Threshold

A company requires transactions exceeding $25,000 to receive senior management approval.


The auditor evaluates transactions immediately below, at, and above the threshold.


The auditor determines whether the system enforces the documented approval rules.


However, the auditor should also consider:

  • Whether the configuration changed during the audit period.

  • Whether users could override the control.

  • Whether access to modify approval limits was restricted.

  • Whether relevant IT general controls were effective.

  • Whether the test environment reflects the production configuration.


Testing one automated transaction does not automatically establish that the control operated throughout the period.


15. Recalculation and Reperformance Using Excel and Data Analytics

Audit software can make both procedures more efficient.


Recalculation Using Excel

Auditors may use Excel to independently calculate:

  • Interest expense.

  • Depreciation.

  • Inventory extensions.

  • Payroll amounts.

  • Sales commissions.

  • Financial statement totals.


A critical safeguard is to avoid simply copying management's formulas without independent evaluation.


If the auditor reproduces an incorrect formula, the resulting recalculation may fail to identify the error.


Reperformance Using Data Analytics

Auditors may use data analytics to independently apply business rules.


For example, an auditor may evaluate every purchase transaction to determine whether required approval levels were met.


The auditor may also identify:

  • Payments without matching receiving records.

  • Purchases exceeding authorized limits.

  • Duplicate invoice numbers.

  • Unauthorized changes to vendor information.

  • Transactions processed outside established approval procedures.


However, applying a business rule to historical data does not by itself establish that the organization's control operated at the required time.


The auditor must distinguish between independently identifying exceptions and obtaining evidence that management's control actually functioned.


16. How Artificial Intelligence Can Support These Procedures

Artificial intelligence can assist auditors in planning, performing, and documenting recalculation and reperformance.


Potential applications include:

  • Generating independent calculation formulas.

  • Identifying inconsistent financial data.

  • Analyzing large transaction populations.

  • Comparing transaction attributes against established control criteria.

  • Identifying missing approvals.

  • Reviewing reconciliation exceptions.

  • Summarizing control failures.

  • Drafting preliminary audit workpapers.


Example AI Prompt

"Review the attached accounts payable transaction file and the documented three-way matching control. Identify the required control criteria. Independently compare purchase orders, receiving records, and invoices for each selected transaction. Report missing documents, quantity differences, price differences, and approval exceptions. Distinguish between verified exceptions and items requiring additional evidence. Do not assume that the existence of matching documents proves the control was performed at the required time."


AI outputs require validation.


The auditor must establish that the source data is sufficiently reliable and that the AI system applied the correct criteria.


AI-generated conclusions should not replace professional judgment or required audit evidence.


17. Common Mistakes Auditors Make


Mistake 1: Treating Recalculation as Validation of the Entire Transaction

Correct arithmetic does not establish authorization, occurrence, completeness, or proper accounting classification.


Mistake 2: Treating a Signed Document as Proof of an Effective Control

Approval evidence may not demonstrate the precision or substance of the review.


Mistake 3: Reperforming the Wrong Procedure

The auditor independently performs a procedure different from the control management was supposed to execute.


Mistake 4: Using Unverified Source Data

The auditor recalculates amounts without evaluating the reliability of underlying data.


Mistake 5: Ignoring Control Frequency

A single successful reperformance is used to support an unsupported conclusion about year-round operation.


Mistake 6: Failing to Investigate Exceptions

Differences are documented without determining their causes or implications.


Mistake 7: Inadequate Workpaper Documentation

The workpapers state that recalculation or reperformance was completed without showing the procedures, inputs, evidence, exceptions, and conclusions.


18. Audit Documentation: What Should Be Recorded?

PCAOB AS 1215 establishes requirements for audit documentation.


A well-designed workpaper should clearly demonstrate the procedure performed and the basis for the auditor's conclusion.

Documentation element

Recalculation

Reperformance

Audit objective

Mathematical accuracy

Operation of a specified procedure or control

Population

Calculations or records tested

Control occurrences or transactions tested

Source evidence

Data and assumptions used

Procedures, policies, records, and control criteria

Procedure performed

Independent computation

Independent execution of the control or procedure

Results

Expected versus recorded amounts

Expected versus observed control outcomes

Exceptions

Calculation differences

Control deviations or processing exceptions

Conclusion

Accuracy of tested calculations

Evidence about the specified control objective

Workpapers should identify who performed the work, when it was performed, and the relevant evidence.


Weak Documentation

"Recalculated payroll. No exceptions."


Stronger Documentation

"Selected 25 payroll transactions from the defined population. Agreed pay rates to authorized personnel records and hours to supporting time records. Independently recalculated gross compensation using applicable pay rules. Compared expected amounts with payroll records and investigated identified differences. Results and supporting evidence are documented in workpaper PAY-04."


For reperformance, the workpaper should similarly describe the control criteria, independent procedures, results, and limitations of the evidence.


19. Practical Audit Testing Checklist

Before concluding on recalculation or reperformance procedures, auditors should answer the following questions.

Question

Recalculation

Reperformance

Has the audit objective been clearly defined?

✓

✓

Has the relevant population been identified?

✓

✓

Has the reliability of source information been evaluated?

✓

✓

Are the relevant calculation or control criteria understood?

✓

✓

Was the work independently executed?

✓

✓

Were differences investigated?

✓

✓

Was the effect of exceptions evaluated?

✓

✓

Was control frequency considered where applicable?

—

✓

Was evidence of management's actual control operation evaluated?

—

✓

Are the procedures and conclusions adequately documented?

✓

✓

The checklist is a practical audit aid, not a substitute for the requirements of applicable auditing standards.


20. Final Thoughts: Independent Verification Makes Audit Evidence Stronger

Recalculation and reperformance are fundamental audit techniques.


Both reduce dependence on unsupported management representations by allowing auditors to independently evaluate financial information and control procedures.


However, the techniques answer different questions.


Recalculation asks: Is the mathematical calculation correct?


Reperformance asks: What happens when the auditor independently executes the procedure or control?


Neither procedure automatically establishes that all relevant financial statement assertions are satisfied or that an internal control operated effectively throughout the audit period.


Auditors must evaluate the relevance and reliability of the evidence, investigate exceptions, and determine whether additional procedures are necessary.


The central lesson is straightforward:


A calculation can be correct while the transaction is wrong. A control can work when the auditor performs it while failing when management is responsible for executing it.


Effective auditing requires understanding both distinctions.

Authoritative References


About Corporate Compliance Seminars

Corporate Compliance Seminars (CCS) provides Continuing Professional Education (CPE) programs for external auditors, internal auditors, accounting professionals, compliance personnel, and information technology professionals.


Our training programs cover audit evidence, internal control testing, PCAOB auditing standards, SOX compliance, COSO, audit documentation, data analytics, and the use of artificial intelligence in auditing.


Explore upcoming training programs at www.compliance-seminars.com.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


Contact Us

Please white list the email address johnb@cseminars.com to allow for CCS emails to reach you effectively.

Thanks for submitting!

Corporate Compliance Seminars is registered with the National Association of State Boards of Accountancy (NASBA) as a sponsor of continuing professional education on the National Registry of CPE Sponsors. State boards of accountancy have final authority on the acceptance of individual courses for CPE credit. Complaints regarding registered sponsors may be submitted to the National Registry of CPE Sponsors through its website: www.nasbaregistry.org.

​

In accordance with the standards of the National Registry of CPE Sponsors, CPE credits are granted based on a 50-minute hour.

​

National Registry of CPE Sponsors ID #108983

​

Complaints may also be forwarded to the company principals, David S. Marshall (708-205-2366; davem@cseminars.com) and/ or John Blackshire (479-200-4373; johnb@cseminars.com)

 

​

bottom of page