top of page
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Linkedin
Search

Folding the PCAOB into the SEC Will Weaken Audit Oversight, Not Strengthen It

Senator Scott,


As a fellow South Carolinian, a proud graduate of the University of South Carolina, and someone who had his first audit failure just down the road from where you grew up, I’m writing with deep concern about your proposal to eliminate the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) and fold its responsibilities into the Securities and Exchange Commission.


My first audit failure—one I’ll never forget—was at the South Carolina Farm Bureau Export Elevator in 1976. That experience taught me the weight and responsibility we carry as auditors. Since then, I’ve watched the evolution of audit regulation with the perspective only decades in the field can give. The PCAOB is far from perfect—but dissolving it into the SEC would not fix what’s broken. It would make things worse.Let me explain why.


Folding the PCAOB Into the SEC Will Undermine Oversight

The SEC Is Not Built for Specialized Audit Oversight- The PCAOB has a singular mission: inspect, regulate, and improve the audits of public companies.- The SEC’s mandate is far broader. It does not have the financial audit expertise or structural independence to fulfill this role at the same standard.- Worse, if PCAOB staff are moved to federal pay scales, we will lose the experienced, technically trained professionals we need most. Audit quality will suffer, full stop.

The Real Problems with the PCAOB—And How to Fix Them

Not One PCAOB Board Member Has Been an Audit Partner- This is the biggest blind spot in PCAOB governance. How can you regulate what you’ve never practiced?- The board’s lack of experience results in unrealistic expectations, tone-deaf standard-setting, and inspections that often miss the forest for the trees.


Chronic Staff Turnover- The PCAOB bleeds talent. It’s hard to maintain consistent standards when inspectors are learning on the job.- This leads to inconsistent inspections, conflicting guidance, and erosion of trust with the firms they're regulating.


Inspectors Are Reviewing Workpapers for Industries They Don’t Understand- I've seen inspectors with zero experience in banking reviewing complex financial services audits.- This mismatch leads to bad assumptions and irrelevant findings—and does nothing to improve audit quality.


No Use of AI or Modern Technology- In 2025, the PCAOB still doesn't use AI to review workpapers. Everything is locked down “for risk.”- While audit firms are adopting advanced analytics and automation, the regulator remains stuck in manual mode. That’s not forward-looking oversight—it’s inefficient and outdated.


No Quality Control Guidance or Grading of Findings- The PCAOB doesn’t provide firms with a framework for proactive quality control.- Worse, their inspection reports don’t label issues as inconsequential, significant, or material. Every finding reads like a disaster—even when it's a low-level process issue.


No Use of the 80/15/5 Rule- In quality control, we know that 80% of issues are low-risk noise, 15% need process tweaks, and 5% are serious.- The PCAOB treats every finding as equally important. That makes it impossible for firms to prioritize what matters most.


Let’s Talk About Cost

You’ve cited a projected $771 million in savings. But here's what many may not realize: not a single tax dollar currently funds the PCAOB. It’s paid for by fees from public companies and audit firms. Moving it to the SEC just shifts the cost into the federal budget. That's not savings—it's accounting smoke and mirrors.

What Needs to Happen Instead

Instead of folding the PCAOB into the SEC, let’s strengthen it:- Appoint experienced audit partners to the board.- Improve retention by creating career paths that value technical expertise.- Use AI and data analytics in inspections.- Provide clear, tiered guidance in inspection reports.- Invest in industry-aligned training for inspectors.These are reforms that will actually protect investors and improve audit quality—not weaken it.

From One South Carolinian to Another

Senator Scott, I’ve seen what happens when audit oversight fails. I’ve lived it. And I know that independence, specialization, and practical experience are not luxuries—they are necessities.Please reconsider your support for this proposal. Let’s work together to fix what’s broken in the PCAOB—not bury it under the bureaucracy of the SEC.


Sincerely,

John C. Blackshire, Jr. Retired CPA

A Proud Gamecock and Veteran A

uditor

 
 
 

Comments


Contact Us

Please white list the email address johnb@cseminars.com to allow for CCS emails to reach you effectively.

Thanks for submitting!

Corporate Compliance Seminars is registered with the National Association of State Boards of Accountancy (NASBA) as a sponsor of continuing professional education on the National Registry of CPE Sponsors. State boards of accountancy have final authority on the acceptance of individual courses for CPE credit. Complaints regarding registered sponsors may be submitted to the National Registry of CPE Sponsors through its website: www.nasbaregistry.org.

In accordance with the standards of the National Registry of CPE Sponsors, CPE credits are granted based on a 50-minute hour.

National Registry of CPE Sponsors ID #108983

Complaints may also be forwarded to the company principals, David S. Marshall (708-205-2366davem@cseminars.com) and/ or John Blackshire (479-200-4373johnb@cseminars.com)

 

At CCS, we are deeply dedicated to delivering NASBA-sponsored Continuing Professional Education (CPE) training events focusing on vital subjects such as risk management, audit & assurance, internal controls, internal audit, cybersecurity, and compliance. Our educational content is meticulously crafted to be accessible through live webinars and in-person CPE events, custom-tailored to meet the CPE requirements of certifications including CIA, CPA, CISA, CFE, and other professional certifications.

We take immense pride in our pivotal role over the past twenty years of empowering participants to expand their audit expertise and develop a deep understanding of best-practice frameworks and standards established by eminent organizations such as IIA, AICPA, COSO Framework, PCAOB Auditing Standards, NAIC Model Laws, GAO Green Book, GAO Yellow Book, NIST, ISO, CMMC, ACFE, SEC, and IAASB.

Our comprehensive CPE training events provide invaluable insights across a diverse spectrum of topics, encompassing internal auditing, external audits, planning and execution of audits using the PCAOB Auditing Standards, formulation and implementation of effective internal audits, risk identification and evaluation, adherence to accounting and auditing standards, proficient management of business endeavors and projects, ITGCs and application controls, vigilant oversight of vendor and third-party risks, robust cybersecurity initiatives, and the reporting of audit, risk management, and internal control training courses.

Furthermore, we offer our professional attendees the opportunity to engage with our webinar CPE events virtually, featuring live instructors, or to participate in-person at select cities or a location of their choice.

We consider our target audience to include chief audit executives, audit partners in CPA firms, chief compliance officers, audit managers, audit supervisors, external auditors, internal auditors, internal control professionals, quality control professionals, compliance professionals, board members, and other professionals who prioritize continuous improvement and organizational sustainability.

Our CPE events are all based on the professional standards provided by the IIA, AICPA, PCAOB Auditing Standards, SEC, ISACA, ACFE, NAIC regulations, NIST, ISO, CMMC, COSO Framework, GAO Yellow Book, GAO Green Book, U.S. GAAP, IFRS, and IAASB.

The CCS training staff has a broad range of experience in internal auditing, Big 4 auditing, software development and implementation, Big 4 consulting, governmental accounting and auditing, regulatory compliance and professional training.

Our flexibility in delivering content allows us to cater to the diverse needs of our professional audit function, internal control professional and information technology participants, ensuring a truly enriching learning experience for all.

Explore our CPE event offerings and sign up for your first CPE training event today!

bottom of page